Surgical Solutions To The Problem Of Massive Weight Loss
Jason A Spector, Steven M Levine, Nolan S Karp
Abstract: In response to the global rise in obesity, bariatric surgery has become increasingly more popular and successful. As a result, the demand for body contouring following massive weight loss is rapidly growing. Although bariatric procedures may produce impressive weight loss, people who achieve massive weight loss are often unhappy with the hanging folds of skin and subcutaneous tissue that remain. This review examines the nature of the post-bariatric deformity in each body region and brieﬂy reviews common approaches to their treatment.
Key words: Weight loss; Bariatric surgery; Body contour surgery
As we enter the 21st century, a new health crisis has dawned upon affluent western societies, the plague of obesity. In the United States, the situation is particularly acute with recent estimates showing that nearly 65% of adult Americans (127 million) are over their ideal body weight, 30% (48 million) are obese [Body mass index (BMI) >30], and nearly 5% (9 million) are morbidly or severely obese (BMI > 40). Further, the obesity epidemic has expanded globally, with approximately one-fifth of the one billion overweight or obese people in the world being Chinese. Although the ultimate impact of mild obesity on survival has recently been challenged, there is no doubt that morbid or severe obesity is detrimental to both the physical and psychological well being of the afflicted patient. Morbidly obese patients have often reached a point of no return in which they are too large and physically unable to exercise.
With some exceptions, the feed-forward cycle of weight gain in the morbidly obese can be interrupted only by physically restricting oral intake. This surgical subspecialty, known as bariatric surgery, has exploded in popularity in the last decade largely because of improved outcomes, enhanced patient safety and superior techniques and devices. Although early bariatric procedures produced impressive weight loss, they also resulted in significant morbidity both initially because of wound healing problems and anastomotic leakage, and ultimately as a result of their malabsorptive effects. Modern laparascopic surgical approaches have minimized wound healing morbidity, while the improvement of more restrictive procedures, such as the minimally invasive LAP-Band®, have made weight loss surgery in morbidly obese patients a reliable and relatively safe procedure. According to the most recent available data, approximately 170 000 bariatric surgeries were performed in the United States in 2005.
However, for the morbidly obese patient, the massive weight loss that follows successful bariatric surgery is only the ﬁrst step in the process. After massive weight loss, patients are left “deflated”. The excess skin that hangs from the torso, abdomen and extremities is not only extremely unsightly, but can be painful and susceptible to recurrent intertriginous infections. In order for these patients to complete their transformation to a formerly morbidly obese patient, a plastic surgeon must address the deformities resulting from the massive weight loss.
This type of extreme body contouring has grown concomitantly with the popularity of bariatric surgery, with 55 927 procedures performed in 2004. More than just excising excess skin and subcutaneous tissue, post-bariatric body contouring requires unique insights into the nature of the post-bariatric deformities. In addition, there must be an appreciation of the fact that massive weight loss patients, because they are often relatively malnourished or anemic, constitute a distinct surgical cohort that must be carefully evaluated pre-operatively. In the following sections, we will examine the nature of the post-bariatric deformity in each body region and brieﬂy review common approaches to their treatment.
In formulating a strategic approach to the massive weight loss patient, the abdomen is usually the ﬁ rst body territory addressed. The appropriate surgical intervention depends upon the amount and distribution of excess skin and subcutaneous tissue as well as the degree of abdominal wall laxity/integrity. In general, as the amount of weight loss increases, so does the aggressiveness of the surgical intervention.
For skin excess limited to the anterior abdomen, as might occur after moderate weight loss or pregnancy, a traditional abdominoplasty will sufﬁce. In this procedure, the skin and subcutaneous tissue between the umbilicus and pubis is excised in an elliptical pattern, leaving a scar concealed within the underwear/bikini line. Since there is usually an associated abdominal wall laxity, prior to closing the incision, the anterior abdominal fascia is plicated, with particular emphasis on re-creation of an appropriate waist in females.
In some weight loss patients, the resulting abdominal pannus consisting of loose hanging skin and subcutaneous tissue can be the source of significant discomfort, recurrent infection and difﬁculty with personal hygiene. A simple elliptical excision of the pannus, which can weigh 25 kg or more, can provide immediate relief of the aforementioned symptoms, with minimal morbidity. In addition, a panniculectomy is often the only post weight loss surgery that may be covered by a third party payer.
In most massive weight loss patients, however, the excess skin and subcutaneous tissue is not conﬁned solely to the anterior abdomen. In order to excise this “conelike” circumferential excess, a circumferential excision or “belt lipectomy” is required. The amount of tissue removed is tailored to the individual patient’s needs. An optimal excision will not only tighten and ﬂatten the lower abdomen but will also give a beneﬁcial lift to the buttocks, mons pubis and lateral thighs.
In some patients (usually those with the most significant excess), the circumferential excision alone is not sufﬁcient to address the horizontal dimension of the excess tissue. In these patients, an anterior ellipse or ﬂeur-de-lis pattern of excision is required. For patients who have had previous “open” bariatric surgery (and therefore already have a vertical midline scar), the additional scar burden is minimal. Even for patients without a pre-existing midline scar, the trade-off for optimal abdominal contour is usually acceptable.
Massive weight loss patients undergoing abdominal contouring procedures often have associated abdominal hernias which are not always evident on pre-operative physical exam. The surgeon should be prepared to repair these in the course of the abdominal contouring. General complications of abdominal contouring include skin necrosis, persistent parasthesias of the abdominal wall, seroma, infection and wound dehiscence. Patients are encouraged to refrain from smoking for at least 3 wk prior to surgery, as tobacco use has been shown to signiﬁcantly increase the morbidity of body contouring procedures.
Following massive weight loss, in both males and females, excess rolls (sometimes three or more per side) of skin and subcutaneous tissue remain. Because of firm underlying fascial attachments, though these may be improved somewhat by belt lipectomy, they can only be completely ablated by direct excision. Usually, the deformity caused by these folds is signiﬁcant enough that patients are willing to trade a horizontal scar across the upper back (hidden in the bra line in females). Furthermore, in women this excess tissue may be transferred anteriorly and used for autologous breast augmentation (see breast discussion below).
The major deformity of the breast after massive weight loss in both men and women is ptosis or sagging of the breast which leaves the nipple areola complex (NAC) below its appropriate anatomic position. In males, the aim is to excise the excess skin and subcutaneous tissue while maintaining a flat breast profile. Various patterns of excision exist to achieve this goal. In extreme cases where the NAC must be moved a long distance superiorly (more commonly in females), it can be removed and replaced as a full thickness skin graft. Patients must be warned that this will cause the NAC to become insensate and may lead to de-pigmentation.
Although the NAC can be returned to its normal anatomic position by various means (at the level of the inframammary fold for women), a major challenge in female weight loss patients is recreation of breast fullness and projection. In most cases of massive weight loss, women are left with deﬂ ated empty “pancake” breasts. For female patients, the goal is to excise excess breast envelope skin while preserving as much volume as possible.
For most massive weight loss patients, satisfactory volume and projection can only be achieved with breast implants placed in combination with a breast lifting skin excision or mastopexy. The choice of implant used for breast augmentation is currently limited to saline-filled, silicone-shelled devices or (for surgeons involved in certain manufacturer study protocols) silicone-filled, silicone-shelled devices (since 1992 the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has banned the routine use of silicone-ﬁ lled implants in the United States, although they remain largely the implants of choice in Europe and the rest of the world and are available to a handful of surgeons in the United States who are part of ongoing clinical trials concerning their use).
The most common complication of these devices (regardless of the implant ﬁ ller material used) is capsular contracture, in which excessive ﬁ brous scar tissue forms around the implant leading to firmness, distortion of the implant and pain. Implant removal or revision of excessive scar tissue may be required in 15%-35% of cases. Other known but less frequent complications of breast implants are infection, malposition and rupture. Breast implants have not been shown to cause autoimmune disorders or increase the risk of (delayed detection) of breast cancer, although special mammographic views may be required.
In some patients, autologous volume augmentation can be achieved by recruiting local folds of tissue that might be otherwise excised in the course of body contouring. Most commonly the excess folds of the upper lateral chest or back tissue are de-epithelialized and rotated anteriorly into the breast. Other surgeons utilize excess tissue on the upper anterior abdomen from a “reverse abdominoplasty”. Common complications of breast lift with or without autologous augmentation are hematoma, infection, seroma and changes in NAC appearance and sensitivity (although many massive weight loss patients have little or no NAC sensitivity pre-operatively). In rare instances, the NAC may be partially or totally lost secondary to ischemic changes caused by surgery and patients should be fully informed pre-operatively of this unfortunate possibility.
Contour deformities of the extremities after massive weight loss can be quite significant. Large amounts of excess skin draped from the proximal half of the arm gives the appearance of a “bat wing”, while excess skin hanging from the thigh is unsightly and prevents patients from wearing bathing suits and shorts. The unsightly appearance of their extremities will often prompt patients to wear long sleeves and pants at all times. To correct these deformities, the excess tissue must be directly excised. The pattern of excision used is similar for both the arms and the legs, since the deformity is essentially the same (a circumferential excess).
For patients with a mild excess of tissue, the incision can usually be hidden in either the axilla (for a brachioplasty or arm lift) or the groin (for a thigh lift) using an elliptical pattern of excision perpendicular to the long axis of the extremity. This type of excision (“mini” brachioplasty or thigh lift) is usually insufﬁcient to correct the amount of excess skin present in most massive weight loss patients.
For more signiﬁcant deformities, an ellipse parallel to the longitudinal axis of the extremity is utilized, with or without the aforementioned perpendicular ellipse. Although this approach can provide remarkable improvement, brachioplasty scars are long and tend to hypertrophy. Furthermore, contractures across the axilla may occur despite use of “z-plasty” designs. For brachioplasty, the longitudinal scar is best placed along the medial surface of the upper arm where it is not visible while the patient’s arms are at rest. Similarly, for thigh lifts a scar is best placed medially along the thigh, although some surgeons advocate use of an anteriorly or laterally based excision. Patients must be thoroughly counseled regarding the inevitable scars as well as other common complications, such as persistent edema, parasthesias and dysesthesias as well as delayed wound healing, particularly in the groin area.
SUCTION-ASSISTED LIPECTOMY (LIPOSUCTION, SAL)
Although some patients may experience an evenly distributed massive weight loss resulting in a relatively thin layer of subcutaneous tissue throughout their body, for most patient this is not the case. In order to address these recalcitrant adipose deposits which are common in the upper abdomen, back, flanks, arms and legs, plastic surgeons utilize suction-assisted lipectomy (SAL), more commonly known as liposuction. Liposuction is not for weight loss, although as much as 6-8 liters or more of fat may be removed safely in a single session. Liposuction is used to “sculpt” areas of the body that need further refinement in their contour. SAL, like most procedures, is effective and safe when performed by a board certified plastic surgeon in an appropriately monitored setting. Although SAL alone is commonly performed as an ambulatory procedure, when more than 5 liters of lipoaspirate is removed in one session, the procedure is considered “large volume” liposuction and overnight monitoring is required. SAL may be used concurrently with any of the above mentioned contouring procedures, or may be used afterwards to fine tune the results. Although not very painful, liposuction can prolong swelling and edema when used in conjunction with other body contouring procedures. A less frequent complication of SAL is persistent seroma. Transient parasthesias and bruising may also occur after SAL.
SEQUENCE OF SURGERY
Body contouring after massive weight loss is a signiﬁcant undertaking on the part of both the surgeon and the patient. As stated earlier, many of these patients are chronically malnourished which predisposes them to increased surgical morbidity. The surgery itself is laborious and sometimes involves considerable blood loss. For these reasons, most surgeons stage the procedures. Usually the abdomen and torso are treated first and, in less severe cases, may be combined with brachioplasty, thigh lift and or breast lift. The number of procedures performed at one time depends upon the health of the patient and the number of surgeons available. In centers where a “total body lift” is performed, two teams operating simultaneously are mandatory to limit time under anesthesia, although such procedures may still take eight or more hours.
As mentioned previously, special consideration must be given to the massive weight loss patient, since they are often relatively malnourished and even anemic secondary to their weight loss. Although severe complications such as pulmonary embolism or even death are relatively rare (0.02% or less), minor complications such as seroma, infection or delayed wound healing are common with some surgeons reporting a greater than 70% total complication rate, especially in refractory smokers. However, most patients will gladly trade these minor complications for the signiﬁcant improvements in their body contour and by direct extension, their self image and conﬁdence.
MOLECULAR ADVANCES IN WEIGHT LOSS
Few drugs remain approved for weight loss. The dearth of pharmaceutical solutions is not for a lack of effort on the part of medical researches, but rather the complex nature of obesity. Most promising advances in weight loss technology surround the hormones leptin and ghrelin, and the peptide known as PYY. These molecules all help regulate mechanisms of obesity. Currently, pharmaceutical companies are developing a variety of compounds to modulate the effects of these compounds.
Body contouring after bariatric surgery is currently the fastest growing ﬁeld within plastic surgery. At the same time, body contouring after massive weight loss continues to evolve as surgeons reﬁne patient selection, technique, and improve safety. However, the surge in weight loss-related surgeries has resulted in ethical questions, such as who should be treated, which operation is best, and who should be performing the surgeries. For these reasons, national consortiums have been founded to develop consensus responses to some of these questions. Meanwhile, though post-bariatric surgery is associated with a greater frequency of complications than “traditional” body contouring, the major transformation imparted by these procedures results in a high degree of patient satisfaction.